Gottlob freges contributions to philosophy of language are so numerous and so fundamental that it is difficult to imagine the field without them. This principle is also called freges principle, because gottlob frege is widely credited for the first modern formulation of it. Pdf reading philosophy of language download full pdf. On the compositionality of idioms an abstract approach dag westerst. Compositionality is a key concept in linguistics, the philosophy of mind and language, and throughout the cognitive sciences. Alberta we prove a theorem stating that any semantics can be encoded as a compositional semantics, which means that, essentially, the standard definition of compositionality is formally vacuous, says zadrozny. Understanding how it works is a central element of syntactic and semantic analysis and a challenge for models of cognition. Principles of compositionality provide precise statements of this idea. The meaning of language when you know a language you know. Compositionality and other issues in the philosophy of.
The philosophy of language became so pervasive that for a time, in analytic philosophy circles, philosophy as a whole was understood to be a matter of philosophy of language. Entries are written by experts in the fields of linguistics and the philosophy of language to reflect the full range of approaches and modes of thought. The principle of semantic compositionality some times called freges principle is the principle that the meaning of a syntactically complex whole is a function only of the meanings. To begin to clarify some of these views we need a framework for talking about compositionality that is suf. In the first place, pagins area is philosophy of language, and within philosophy of language he has primarily taken an interest in the foundations of semantic theories and semantic concepts. This unique textbook introduces linguists to key issues in the philosophy of language. I furthermore will be making claims about the notions of. Compositionality and conceptsa perspective from formal semantics and philosophy of language francis je. This paper is an investigation into these differing antecedent ideas in the realm of meaning and compositionality as they play out in linguistics, cognitive psychology, and philosophy of language. Indeed, the language of thought hypothesis has it that thought, being language like in certain essential respects, is a language. Language, thought and compositionality royal institute. Find materials for this course in the pages linked along the left.
Philosophy of language is the reasoned inquiry into the origins of language, the nature of meaning, the usage and cognition of language, and the relationship between language and reality. The following survey will evaluate various semantic theories according to how well they explain compositionality, reference, and other important characteristics of natural languages. During a couple of years he has worked on the principle of compositionality for natural language. A bibliography of online papers in philosophy of language. When a word is meaningful or meaningless, when a word has two meanings, when two words have the same meaning, and what words refer to in the real world or imagination when a sentence is meaningful or meaningless, when a. A compositional semantics for a language is a finite theory which explains how semantically important properties such as truthconditions are determined by the meanings of parts and syntax. Philosophy of language by branch doctrine the basics. There are many theses called the principle of compositionality. Pdf compositionality and conceptsa perspective from. Because its investigations are conceptual rather than empirical, the philosophy of language is distinct from linguistics, though. Philosophy of language chapter one the logical study of language 7 1. In this book leading scholars from every relevant field report on the state of the art in all aspects of the subject.
This article discusses freges apparently metaphysical doctrine that concepts are unsaturated. Does the principle of compositionality explain produc ceur. One of the earliest use of word representations dates back to 1986 due to rumelhart, hinton, and williams. Compositionality internet encyclopedia of philosophy. Freges on sense and reference philosophy of language. It overlaps to some extent with the study of epistemology, logic, philosophy of mind and other fields including linguistics and psychology, although for many analytic philosophers it is an important. Compositionality stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Today, compositionality is a key notion in linguistics, philosophy of language, logic, and computer science, but there are divergent views about its exact formulation, methodological status, and empirical signi. Routledge encyclopedia of philosophy philosophy of language. This article begins by developing a precise definition of compositionality. That is, whenever two languages have the same syntactic operation, they. The task of a semantics for language l is to provide truth conditions for every wellformed sentence of l, and to do so in a compositional way.
If in a given language a certain phrase acquires the. Download pdf reading philosophy of language book full free. According to this principle, it is assumed that the whole meaning of a phrase or sentence can be described according to the functional interdependency of the meaning of its parts. Reading philosophy of language available for download and read online in other formats. Recursive deep models for semantic compositionality over a. Action at a distance, sentences true here because of events there. Important variants of the compositionality principle will be presented below in a form most similar to c to facilitate comparisons. One tradition, call it the system perspective, thinks of a language as a collection of formal rules. What is semantics, what is meaning lecture 1 hana filip. In mathematics, semantics, and philosophy of language, the principle of compositionality is the principle that the meaning of a complex expression is determined by the meanings of its constituent expressions and the rules used to combine them. This task requires providing appropriate modeltheoretic interpretations for the parts of the sentence, including the lexical items. Often called mentalese, the mental language resembles spoken language in several key respects. An explanation of gottlob freges solutions to freges puzzle and the problem of propositional attitude reports using freges theory of sense.
Just one more form of intelligent collaborationgames, family, hunting. What is semantics, what is meaning university of florida. Summary philosophy of language refers to an area of philosophy concerned with the syntactic properties as well as the meaning and reference of linguistic expressions, the things implied or indicated by linguistic expressions and the attributes of linguistic expressions as a function of linguistic and conversational contexts. Compositionality is a concept in the philosophy of language. Compositionality in the montague grammar tradition. The oxford handbook of compositionality markus werning. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. Language, thought and compositionality volume 48 jerry fodor. Distributed representations of words in a vector space help learning algorithms to achieve better performancein natural language processing tasks by groupingsimilar words. Key ideas in linguistics and the philosophy of language on.
Compositionality and concepts in linguistics and psychology pp 3194 cite as. Today, compositionality is a key notion in linguistics, philosophy of language. Nevertheless, given the expository purposes of this article, thats mostly what i will do. The analysis of phrase and sentence meaning is based on the principle of compositionality that is usually ascribed to gottlob frege freges principle of meaning, fregean principle. Recursive deep models for semantic compositionality over a sentiment treebank richard socher, alex perelygin, jean y. Lecture notes introduction to philosophy of language. Distributed representations of words and phrases and their. Compositionality routledge encyclopedia of philosophy. Compositionality and other issues in the philosophy of mind and language an interview with jerry fodor by martin l.
Pdf compositionality and other issues in the philosophy. Compositionality and other issues in the philosophy of mind and language an interview with jerry fodor. This book offers introductory entries on 80 ideas that have shaped the study of language up to the present day. There are a number of comprehensive and highquality reference works in philosophy of language, including hale and wright 1997 and lepore and smith 2006. The question of compositionality, however, should be posed for a semantics, notforindividualphrases. A symbolic system is compositional if the meaning of every complex expression e in that system depends on, and depends only on, i es syntactic structure and ii the meanings of es simple parts.
Pdf compositionality and conceptsa perspective from formal. The language of thought hypothesis stanford encyclopedia. The principle of semantic compositionality sometimes called freges principle is the principle that the meaning of a syntactically complex whole is a function only of the meanings of its. It argues that it is primarily a semantic thesis, an essential ingredient of freges conception of compositionality.
As such, compositionality ranks as the distinctively linguistic contribution freges philosophy of logic makes to philosophy of language, not just as a guiding maxim but also in particular aspects of freges more detailed proposals. Principle of compositionality freges principle, a fundamental. Although the appearance of connection between words and the world is familiar to anyone who speaks a language, it is also quite mysterious. Philosophy of language linguistics oxford bibliographies. C the meaning of a complex expression is determined by its structure and the meanings of its constituents. Alexander miller is professor of philosophy at the university of birmingham, uk. The following can serve as a common reference point. Freges contribution to philosophy of language oxford. One feature that thought is usually taken to have in common with language is compositionality. Compositionality and conceptsa perspective from formal. The question of whether natural languages have compositional semantics continues to attract considerable interest, as do questions about the reasons for wanting compositionality, the consequences of compositionality, and the very formulation of the principle of compositionality. The language of thought hypothesis loth proposes that thinking occurs in a mental language. In many cases, the articles or books are written by authors with a serious acquaintance with linguistics. The principle of semantic compositionality francis jeffry pelletier abstract.
968 1316 1072 1138 83 137 1057 887 1372 866 953 53 1372 899 169 691 1581 1355 1556 647 1035 976 1578 1074 1318 1406 162 650 515 1574 107 1495 254 528 45 1232 1434 944 1408 1378 1457